Quantcast
 

Looking Back: Which Party's Convention Was the Best?

Fri, 09/05/2008 - 9:00am by CitizenSugar
796 Views - 59 comments

Phew. I've run into quite a few people over the past few weeks who've seen both conventions top to bottom, and the question came up last night after the last balloon settled: Which convention was the best? In my mind it can be answered on a couple of levels — which convention looked the best, or which was more fun — but when it comes down to it, I think the real question is: Which convention did its job the best?

My mom reported in after McCain's speech saying, "I was worried when McCain started, but was in tears at the end. Your grandpa wanted me to take him to the post office to sign up again." While that's a rousing testimony to be sure, they were solid McCain voters before anyone set foot in St. Paul. So what do you all think? You've seen our coverage of both conventions — which party's did its job with an A++ super-gold star?


on Yahoo!

59 Comments Add a Comment

  • raciccarone's picture
    raciccarone
    2

    I'm still waiting for the Green Party before I participate in this conversation.

    Go Nader!

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • nyaradzom2001's picture
    nyaradzom2001
    3

    well i am not and never will be a fan of the republican party so i found the DNC way more entertaining.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • stiletta's picture
    stiletta
    4

    It's true, if you're a fan of one party I don't think you could sit through the other party's convention. I found myself finding it very hard to listen to the Democrats, but I heard it was a huge spectacle.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • yesteryear's picture
    yesteryear
    5

    i was way more into FURCON2008... the furry convention. both of these conventions were a little lacking in fat guys dressed as simba dolls and humping each other whilst listening to clay aiken. just sayin'

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • mondaymoos's picture
    mondaymoos
    7

    I didn't watch either, to be honest. There's no real substance to any of the parts that are publicized. While I'm sure all the conferances that the press got to attend were very informative and fun for them, I find the rest of it to be distracting, whether it was the DNC or the RNC.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Brendelwoman's picture
    Brendelwoman
    8

    Yeah, I think bias plays way too much into that question. Democrats will say the DNC was better and Republicans will say the RNC was better.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • sexylibrarian's picture
    sexylibrarian
    10

    The DNC was hands down more interesting! I did watch both conventions so I would be informed. I hate when people make assumptions and they have no idea what they are talking about. The only way to truly know what the candidates stand for is to research their beliefs and policies and form an opinion for yourself.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • raciccarone's picture
    raciccarone
    11

    I thought when the RNC sacrificed that bull by slitting its throat was a good throwback to their party's roots.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • hausfrau's picture
    hausfrau
    12

    I don't think watching either convention gets anyone much information. Again, conventions are to rally the base, not inform the voter. If you want information, you have to seek it out yourself.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Jude C's picture
    Jude C
    13

    I'm partial to my party, naturally, but I actually think both sides succeeded at what they set out to do. They each featured rousing speakers who did a great job of energizing their base and constituency, they both defined their platforms in whichever ways they feel are effective (again, I'm partial to one side, but I can see that both were effective at that), and they both came out with their official nominees.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Vespa's picture
    Vespa
    16

    Agreed that it's impossible to answer this questioned unbiased-ly (is that a word?). What conservative is going to be like, oh, the dems put on a great show! or vice versa?

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • sonya ina's picture
    sonya ina
    17

    DNC all the way, no contest. You can't beat 80,000 people and a speech from Obama that put many to tears.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • stephley's picture
    stephley
    18

    I'd be willing to say the Republicans put on a great show for their audience.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • letsgetloud21's picture
    letsgetloud21
    21

    who thought that protester that got her 5 seconds of fame was ugly as hell Barf! was she trying to rip her top off?

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • hausfrau's picture
    hausfrau
    22

    those protestors really pissed me off. they need to go back to kindergarten and learn some manners.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • letsgetloud21's picture
    letsgetloud21
    23

    They teach peace,but then they kick police officers,break windows and ect. and when did hoodies and jeans become one of the dress codes for protesters.The ones I saw outside most of them looked like mad little emo kids.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Jude C's picture
    Jude C
    24

    "mad little emo kids"

    Well, at least that doesn't sound too threatening.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Jude C's picture
    Jude C
    26

    I'll break their skinny, twig-like legs in two before they get anywhere close enough to do that Eye-wink

    Or I'll just make fun of them until they cry. That'd probably work.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Vespa's picture
    Vespa
    27

    Okay, Steph. You would rise above. Smiling But I don't think very many people would say the other team's convention was better.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • desidesi's picture
    desidesi
    28

    I thought it was hilarious when they had the big build up for McCain and then out he comes, walking like a turtle

    I watched both to be fair, but the obnoxious "Drill, baby, drill" chanting made me want to vomit

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Vespa's picture
    Vespa
    30

    Regarding the protestors, I feel like I saw more protestors in the actual convention hall at the RNC than the DNC. Citizen, was that representative? Did the RNC ones just get more camera time? I didn't get why the camera kept panning to the veteran protestor at the very opening of McCain's speech. I would have thought they'd be more regulating of the coverage. I mean, the pubs left nothing to chance, they even made their own hand made signs!

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • Lainetm's picture
    Lainetm
    31

    I'm glad to know which party values "par-tay" over content.

    I think the vote count on this poll explains why some of the commenters here get beaten into submission, though. Kind of like Gulliver and the Lilliputians.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • True Song's picture
    True Song
    33

    Beaten into submission? I think most everyone can hold their own...

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • organicsugr's picture
    organicsugr
    36

    "I think most everyone can hold their own..." That's curious, because when I pointed out the sexism in our own party Torg, my comment got inexplicably removed.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • javsmav's picture
    javsmav
    39

    I'm glad they are over--not a big fan of conventions. I can't even get fired up for my side. I felt obligated to listen to Obama's speech, but for everyone else I just heard about it on NPR the next morning and read people's opinions on CS. I'm just too cynical to get excited about politics.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • snowbunny11's picture
    snowbunny11
    40

    I really hated Giuliani, Palin and the 9/11 video...so the RNC was bad to me, just factually incorrect and offensive. To be fair, I only watched Obama and Clinton at the DNC, maybe they played some offensive video on how if you didn't like books you weren't a liberal!

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • ceej's picture
    ceej
    41

    I thought the lack of humility and aggressive stance of the Republican convention was distasteful given their party's record over the last eight years. Guiliani was particularly smug and insulting.

    12 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • lorenashley's picture
    lorenashley
    45

    that robot cindy mccaint spent almost a million dollars on her yellow outfit....isnt that uppity???

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Lainetm's picture
    Lainetm
    46

    "I thought the culture of victimization was a liberal thing."

    Glad to see it acknowledged, too--thanks!
    I think it's very American to recognize the odds, and hold firmly to your principles in the face of them.

    I think the best example of "lack of humility" this whole election season is Obama's prophet of change persona.

    And I love the fact that any criticism of Obama has to fall into a narrowly-defined range, or it's termed racist. It's appa