Quantcast
 

Evangelicals Lose Faith in Republicans — Church of Obama?

Mon, 05/12/2008 - 7:00am by CitizenSugar
1,038 Views - 176 comments

Young and found Jesus? There's a good chance you may be saying, "yes, we can." According to a September 2007 survey by the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life, 15 percent of white evangelicals between 18 and 29 — those who could traditionally be counted on to vote Republican — say they no longer identify with the Republican Party. (Older evangelicals are also questioning their allegiance, although not as dramatically.) What's turning young evangelicals to Obama?

One seminary student summed it up like this: "I just keep thinking, if Jesus were alive now, he wouldn't necessarily be voting Republican." To see where the schism happens, read more.

Young Christians are just as passionate about the "family values" issues that have traditionally driven Christians to the Republican camp (a study by an evangelical polling organization shows young Christians are actually more conservative than older generations on abortion) but they're also concerned about issues such as social justice and immigration — issues traditionally addressed by Democrats. The crisis of conservatism stems from young evangelicals being "both socially conservative and globally aware." McCain doesn't speak to them on the former issue, so they're searching for a representative on the latter.

Robert Novak has an Op-Ed in the Washington Post today where he highlights McCain's faith-based problem, and questions the role of Mike Huckabee — could he be the religious savior that McCain needs, or does he have devilish intentions? Novak says this, which I find startling:

One experienced, credible activist in Christian politics who would not let his name be used told me that Huckabee, in personal conversation with him, had embraced the concept that an Obama presidency might be what the American people deserve. That fits what has largely been a fringe position among evangelicals: that the pain of an Obama presidency is in keeping with the Bible's prophecy.

Are you surprised by this evangelical phenomenon? Can McCain win over the socially conservative? Should he even try? Would an Obama presidency be a plague of biblical proportions — or heaven on earth?

Source

on Yahoo!

Related Citizen Stories

Related Network Stories


 
 
 

176 Comments Add a Comment

  • UnDave35's picture
    UnDave35
    1

    90% of the students in seminary when my wife went through we VERY left wing democrats. That may just be the denomination, but I have noticed a tendancy for students and just graduated worker tend to be democrats. It makes sense. Those who don't have a lot want everyone to share. They'll get more conservative as they get older Evil

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • megnmac's picture
    megnmac
    2

    I think that there has long been a divide for those voting on Christian principles, who both want to take on helping the poor and believe in giving to those in need, but also socially are pushed out by the outspoken on the left (weren't we just talking about planned parenthood pushing people?)...

    Obama captured my interest when he came onto the national scene b/c he was able to comfortably embrace religion/spirituality and still be embraced by the Dem base. Bush won over a lot of people through churches, especially the black churches, and I think it will be interesting to see if Obama is a candidate that can bring those people back. Not by pandering or bribing, but by showing that we are a coalition of people with similar needs and interests and that he can meet those needs.

    I hope so...

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • stiletta's picture
    stiletta
    3

    Although I am glad Evangelicals are involved in politics, voting for someone because they believe he will be an infliction to our nation is medieval at best.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • syako's picture
    syako
    5

    I found it on my own, ok here's what I see - while the Republican affiliation has decreased by 15% since 2001 among 18-29 white evangelical Christians, the independents have increased by 6% and the dems have only increased by 3%. So I don't think it's safe to assume that all these independents would vote Obama?

    To be honest, the infiltration of evangelicals into the Republican party has actually made me wish and hope for the rise of the Libertarian party because I am strongly opposed to mixing religion and politics, there's a reason there's a separation between church and state.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • cine_lover's picture
    cine_lover
    7

    That is fine with me. It could help the Republican party go back to the true Conservative roots! Bye Religious Right Wave

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • syako's picture
    syako
    8

    The plague thing is Hagee-crazy, if you ask me.

    And in reference to the Jesus quote, I definitely don't think he'd be affiliated with either party to be honest. Plus there'd be bigger fish to fry than choosing a candidate, imo.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • cine_lover's picture
    cine_lover
    9

    Sy, You and me both wish there would be a rise in Libertarians. Actually I wish Republicans would go back to being Conservative, but I will take what I can get at this point!

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • UnDave35's picture
    UnDave35
    10

    I agree Sy. Neither party would pass the Jesus test. Both parties would send their lawyers and argue that they could, but that's the problem with spin. Lot's get said, and little gets done.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • zeze's picture
    zeze
    13

    "To be honest, the infiltration of evangelicals into the Republican party has actually made me wish and hope for the rise of the Libertarian party because I am strongly opposed to mixing religion and politics, there's a reason there's a separation between church and state"

    Exactly!

    Thanks for saying it, I had not figured this out to be honest. While I still think I'm neither Democrat nor Republican per se, I do think that is a huge reason why I can't commit to Republican. I cannot stand all the religious restrictions that the Republican party endorses, I feel like the Republican party is schizophrenic sometimes, endorsing small government in some but allowing heavy regulation when religion is involved.

    The Democratic party is too much all around for me, too much government, too much taxes, too much regulation, too much everything it seems.

    I used to identify as a Republican more than anything but the last 8 years of Bush's "spiritual" politics have been a HUGE TURN OFF.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • KrisSugar's picture
    KrisSugar
    17

    If Jesus were here, He would tell that student to stop putting words in his mouth. Nothing annoys me more than people talking about what Jesus would say or do so specifically.

    This is just so depressing to me I can't think of anything to say about it. Ditto to all of you guys!

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • hausfrau's picture
    hausfrau
    18

    did anyone else get a chuckle out of this part? "One experienced, credible activist in Christian politics who would not let his name be used told..."

    All I could think of is, Well, if ONE person says it, it must be true!

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • syako's picture
    syako
    19

    For true cab, I know that's how it goes in my world, one person said it, then it's the truth no matter what!

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • hausfrau's picture
    hausfrau
    20

    I also find it hard to believe that while McCain doesn't speak to the socially conservative, Obama does?

    I think this has more to do with the common misconception that Obama is moderate than it has to do with people leaving the Republican party by the boatload...

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • hausfrau's picture
    hausfrau
    21

    Or is that to mean the former issue of social justice?

    How does McCain not speak to that?

    I just don't really understand that part.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • hausfrau's picture
    hausfrau
    22

    Ah well, whatever, I'm with you guys, getting the religion out of the GOP is a good thing!

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • zeze's picture
    zeze
    23

    I don't really get it either cabaker, it seems to me since that people who favor more secular politics would leave the right in favor of Obama not the other way around.

    It's like if you are on a diet, the ice cream cone is bad, but the ice cream cake is worse. (not had lunch yet Smiling)

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • cine_lover's picture
    cine_lover
    24

    Barry is rolling over in his grave at what the Republican party has become. He would be making some serious speeches against the religious right, and would probably call himself a Libertarian if it were not for their ideas in Foreign policy, which is really the only thing that keeps me from calling myself a Libertarian.

    I Love you Barry!

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • megnmac's picture
    megnmac
    26

    I agree w/ a lot of ppl about separating church and state... but don't we all vote for policies based on our moral values? How are we ever disentangled? I disagree with legislating someone else's choices, I'm for less govt interference for the most part, but helping the planet and helping the poor and equalizing the playing field for the disadvantaged appeals to me on a core level.

    There is religion, and then there is the state... and then there is how much you want the state to interfere based on your beliefs... and then if you want incentives or if you want the govt to help or if you want to govt to restrict...

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • mymellowman's picture
    mymellowman
    27

    Very well put Cine. If the Libertarians can muster a little support (and hopefully change their forgiven policy) I'm probably going to be leaning in their direction, but until they become more electable, I'm still a Republican.

    I hope you're all doing well.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Jillness's picture
    Jillness
    28

    I think it is great if people that are out side the traditional "obama demographic" are looking into what he really stands for. I think he is a great candidate and offers quite a bit.

    I do think that the past 8 years have been really hard on the lower and middle class in the United States, and so it makes sense that people are questioning how much Republican policy actually translates into Christian principles.

    I think Obama's Fellowship program is TOTALLY something JWD. Training volunteers to go into communities and make them better. It doesn't cost tax payers any money, but it makes a huge impact in the lives of those that are struggling.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • cine_lover's picture
    cine_lover
    31

    Jill I think the last 8 years are a horrible representation of Republican policy, and that is why so many Republicans are fed up and going towards being Libertarian.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • raciccarone's picture
    raciccarone
    32

    So, they're Obama supporters because they believe he will be a sign of the end times? Was that one of his policies? Did I miss that on Meet The Press?

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • hypnoticmix's picture
    hypnoticmix
    33

    Yeah Obama's just a regular Pied Piper, stand too close and it'll look like a scene out of 76 Trombones.

    I think that the season is ripening for a viable third party. Sen. Obama and Sen. McCain are both Mavericks in their own right and they both offer something different for the Clinton/Bush constituents.

    An Obama Presidency won't be heaven or hell, it'll just be different. I for one can't wait to go to Soul Train at the White House.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • jennifer76's picture
    jennifer76
    34

    Cine, you can join my Republitarian party. We are the bane of all on the left and the right.

    This story - although perhaps not portending any real trends given Syako's comments - warms my little heart. This touches on one of the things that I feel is really missing in a lot of socially conservative Christians these days. Jesus was very adamantly for helping the poor and loving and accepting the imperfect. So, support family values, oppose big government, that's all well and good, Jesus certainly didn't put a lot of faith in the government taking care of those who need it. He and his followers took that on. So, what are you doing to carry out that part of his message? I'm not saying that all socially conservative Christians don't. But, it does seem sometimes like that gets a little lost in the wind for some of the vocally religous chunks of the GOP.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • raciccarone's picture
    raciccarone
    36

    I don't mind that the republican party was co-opted by the religious right, I mind that the religious right egregiously abandoned all of their religious tenets so completely once they came to power.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • nicachica's picture
    nicachica
    39

    Does anyone know how to adress rac's concern cuz i have the same question she does!

    "So, they're Obama supporters because they believe he will be a sign of the end times? Was that one of his policies? Did I miss that on Meet The Press?"

    what does that mean? that the Bible prophesied that a half black/half white man with a funny name would become president and then the dogs of Circes would descend upon humanity to devour the unrighteous???

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • syako's picture
    syako
    40

    Maybe it's like the antichrist coming to power before the Son of Man can return? I have no clue nica. Puzzled

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • hausfrau's picture
    hausfrau
    41

    yea i didnt get that part either...

    my brain is having some functioning issues today!

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • hypnoticmix's picture
    hypnoticmix
    42

    Thanks for warning us about the dogs of Circes nicachica. I'll have to stock up on my milk bones and begon strips.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • syako's picture
    syako
    43

    ha that reminds me of the Bud light commercial where dogs can talk. Pretty hilarious.

    34 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • hypnoticmix's picture
    hypnoticmix
    44

    I like the one with the Irish clogging Chimpanzees. Could that be an Oman too? Irish clogging Chimpanzees?