Quantcast
 

Are We All Just Too Easily Offended?

Tue, 04/08/2008 - 1:00pm by CitizenSugar
9,514 Views - 90 comments

I don't know if it's just me, but every news story I read today is another tale of people getting bent out of shape. Have we built a culture of super sensitivity, or are there just so many things to object to nowadays? To the evidence!

  • Barack Obama's campaign has just persuaded a delegate to step down after she was ticketed for describing her neighbor's children's behavior using the word, "monkeys." The kids were playing in the tree next door to her house. According to police, the woman "came outside and told the children to quit playing in the tree like monkeys." The woman says she didn't want the children to get hurt, and she even calls her own grandchildren "monkeys." Why the ticket and her banishment as a delegate? The children were African American. Obama's campaign called her use of the word monkey "divisive and unacceptable."

There's more offensive evidence if you'll just read more.

  • After Absolut Vodka's "In An Absolut World" ad showing Mexico taking over part of the US, people are now calling for a boycott of the liquor. According to the movement's website, they're fired up because "the ad's message to the Mexican audience is "In an Absolut (ie [sic] Perfect) world, 1/3 of the US is returned to Mexican control." Just wait until they get a look at Absolut's brand new ad targeting the gay and lesbian drinking population.
  • At a Texas middle school, a student fulfilling an assignment for history class, "to make a protest sign for or against an issue," chose illegal immigration. The sign she made following the assignment's directions read, "If you love our nation, stop illegal immigration." News of the sign got passed around lunch and angered a group of Latino students — who assaulted her. When she went for help, she was ordered back to class and told she could not call her parents. Her father is calling the incident, "a racially motivated crime."

Are we caught in an ever accelerating loop competing to see just who's more offended? Of who can "reject and denounce" the quickest and loudest? I know I've hit you with three stories that might strike you differently — I'd love to know if you think some are valid points of contention, and some are examples of how we're all just too darn touchy.

Let me know — I promise I won't be offended.

on Yahoo!

90 Comments Add a Comment

  • hausfrau's picture
    hausfrau
    1

    I had to look up that absolut ad with the ruler cuz I didn't get it...

    ... now I do... Smiling

    And yes, very all over sensitive.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • syako's picture
    syako
    3

    um, unrelated, but is there a reason the entire moscow times post was deleted?

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • syako's picture
    syako
    5

    well yeah, but an "update" would have been better imo.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • heineken67's picture
    heineken67
    6

    People seem to go out of their way to find something to be offended about.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Shopaholichunny's picture
    Shopaholichunny
    7

    People need to get over it. That Vodka ad doesn't offend me nor does the word monkeys. It's ridiculous nowadays.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • lilprisci's picture
    lilprisci
    8

    People are extremely over-sensitive about everything. There's a need to feel self-important I think; people don't feel fulfilled unless they're complaining about something, anything.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Hootie's picture
    Hootie
    13

    Oh please!
    I call my son a monkey butt all the time!
    The vodka ads are just liquor ads...
    Stupid humor.

    Now, the girl getting attacked and not being allowed to call her dad is wrong. She did her assignment and was attacked for it. She has a right to be against illegals, just as others have a right to support them, literally. $$$

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • KrisSugar's picture
    KrisSugar
    14

    i (white) am a babysitter of two black boys whom I refer to as "little monkeys." Their momma calls them that, so I figured it was okay! I don't think any of us ever thought twice about it. Their mom always jokes about how dark they are, and if we go out in public people probably think I caught the "jungle fever." She says those kind of things all the time! I just keep my mouth shut.

    I think it's just personal, how things strike you. Here in TX, there is a Dairy Queen commercial where two redneck sherrif deputies are interviewing a cheeseburger. They have it under the spotlight, and they keep calling it "BOY." Now to me, that sounds a little racist, even though there is nothing overtly racist about it. I hate that commercial, and it scares me. Becuase I know there are parts of TX where that treatment is not just in the past. They keep running the spot every year, so I guess no one else sees it that way!

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • MarinerMandy's picture
    MarinerMandy
    15

    Yeah, everyone is WAY oversensitive. And actually, I wouldn't mind too much if Mexico did extend to that part of the United States. There, now I've offended someone!

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • mondaymoos's picture
    mondaymoos
    16

    I've so had it with PCness. It's an ad. If that's up there on your importance in life scale, perhaps you need to re-evaluate your priorities.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • wackdoodle's picture
    wackdoodle
    18

    Barak needs to STFU. I call ALL children monkeys. My company's name is "something" monkey. I used to call my nephews little monkeys and I call my neices my neice-monkeys.

    And for cripessake when my nephews took dance lessons from Patsy and Patrick Swayze, Patsy called every child in her studio her "little monkeys".

    Only a freakin' moron who just discovered his "supposed" racial identity would get all uptight about a woman referring to children as monkeys and demand that she recuse herself as a delegate. I bet she was a Hilary delegate.

    And I guess Barak and Michelle never sing "10 little monkeys" to their daughters while they jumped around. What a freakin' moron. His ignorance knows no bounds since he decided that he's a "black man" not a bi-racial man.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • thorswitch's picture
    thorswitch
    19

    (Ok, now I'm curious about the Moscow Time article - can anyone offer a quick summary? Feel free to send it privately so as not to disrail this convo any further - )

    As for the subject at hand, whether or not someone is "overreacting" is such a subjective concept. If you've not been in someone else's shoes, it may not always be possible to understand how hurtful something might truly be. At the same time, though, sometimes it does seem that the "punishment" may not fit the "crime" very well. Pushing the delegate out because she told kids in a tree they were "acting like monkeys" can, I'm sure, be very hurtful to many African-Americans given how the term "monkey" has historically been used against them and helped perpetuate the idea that blacks are inferior to whites, or, worse, not truly "human" at all.

    So I get why people were upset - but I'm not sure her stepping down as a delegate is truly necessary. I'd like to think this is something that could be resolved with a sincere apology and maybe having the delegate be involved with doing PSA's about how its important to choose your words carefully. Of course, if she hadn't resigned, you just KNOW that both the Clinton and McCain camps would jump on Obama accepting the support of a racist (or something of that nature) - not because they're genuinely offended by what she said, but because they think it can win them votes. Politics are disgusting that way.

    As for the Absolute "Ruler" add, I got the implication of the add immediately, but was surprised when I flipped over to the article to find that it was being used to specifically target the Gay & Lesbian community. Straight guys are just as obsessed with their, uh, dimensions, so it seemed to me that the ad was just poking fun at *all* men, not just gays. Weird.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • hypnoticmix's picture
    hypnoticmix
    20

    Specific to the Monkey statement, that was just stupid. Frolicking climbing children have been referred to as Monkeys for decades because of the obvious inference. What is this crap too about her being ticketed for the comment? WTF!

    I'm gay and I don't' get how the ruler targets the gay community.

    As for the little Latinos attacking the little Anglo it was not racially motivated. It was patriotically motivated and racially perceived.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • esk4's picture
    esk4
    21

    so now its a crime to call children monkeys? is it all children or just black children?

    the only thing I find upsetting is how the girl was treated for completing an assignment...

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • CitizenSugar's picture
    CitizenSugar
    22

    Hi everybody. Thanks for noticing the missing story. It contained some factual errors and was taken down. Thank you for your patience with my early morning confusion. Smiling Please let me know if you have additional questions.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • hypnoticmix's picture
    hypnoticmix
    23

    In addendum to my last comment this is precisely why people need to examine the context of statements and actions before they react quite possibly as illustrated in some cases above with ignorance.

    In my opinion, in most cases it does not matter what something sounds like or looks like. What matters is the intent.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • CaterpillarGirl's picture
    CaterpillarGirl
    24

    like chuck said

    Political correctness is tyranny with manners.

    I call little kids monkeys all the time, and Hoodlums, and I say "the natives are restless"

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Jillness's picture
    Jillness
    25

    "Barak needs to STFU."
    "What a freakin' moron. His ignorance knows no bounds since he decided that he's a "black man" not a bi-racial man."

    That was really articulate. Have you listened to anything he has said about race recently, like that 20 minute long speech? You should re-read that. He is quite familar with the knowledge that he is half white, being that he was raised by his white mother and grandparents.

    Can you really blame politicians for being a bit paranoid about anything that a supporter says? Things have been taken so out of context in so many ways, I understand why he would want to distance himself from anything controversial.

    "Of course, if she hadn't resigned, you just KNOW that both the Clinton and McCain camps would jump on Obama accepting the support of a racist (or something of that nature) - not because they're genuinely offended by what she said, but because they think it can win them votes."

    Exactly.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • thorswitch's picture
    thorswitch
    26

    Yeah, I have a hard time with how the girl was treated for her assignment. I would have had no problem if the Latinos who attacked her had - instead of taking physical retaliation - had opted to make their own protest signs or otherwise *peacefully* expressed their opposition, but I hope that they were punished appropriately for attacking her. I find it almost unbelievable - especially since in the article, the school district says that they do have a tape of the event - that they sent her back to class and told her she couldn't call her parents. Not "unbelievable" in the sense that I think she's lying about it, but unbelievable that the school would actually consider that in any way appropriate!

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • mymellowman's picture
    mymellowman
    27

    Why are we always worried about people being overly sensitive?

    What about the insensitive people like Cine, Cabaker and Sy. Eye-wink

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • ktownpolarbear's picture
    ktownpolarbear
    28

    people are becoming overly-sensitive, no doubt. but the girl who got assaulted by other students? that seems a little extreme to not let her call her parents. although i'm not sure if it's a "racially motivated crime."

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • UnDave35's picture
    UnDave35
    29

    I agree that we are way oversensitive as a country. We have been brought up looking for ways that comments could be construed as offensive, and not necessarily taking the comment at face value. The delegat who was asked to step down and ticketed has been unfairly treated, and she has my sympathy

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • MandyJoBo's picture
    MandyJoBo
    30

    None of those are offensive to me. I'm not really offended by anything unless it is directed at me personally--either by confrontation, or cowardly passive-aggression--and I think it is a waste of time to get riled up over something so trivial. If people find ads or a little girl's opinion offensive and want to spend energy and time rolling it over in their minds, then I just find it sad that it isn't something that will result in a positive outcome. Something such as world hunger or animal welfare; something that will make them get off their butts and do something to better the world rather than sit and stew over something harming no one. But, perhaps if there weren't people who got offended over ads and other seemingly trivial things, maybe there would be less sensitively in general and that would be a very bad thing for humanity. I guess it's all copacetic (I swear I'll never use that word again), and everyone plays a part in the grand scheme of things. Like Mosquitoes.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • raciccarone's picture
    raciccarone
    31

    I'm actually really offended that you think I'm too easily offended. Where the hell do you get off, Citizen!

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • KrisSugar's picture
    KrisSugar
    32

    But Hypnotic, we do not know that it was not racially motivated.

    I grew up in Texas schools and there IS racism against Hispanic people. It's often subtle, but it's pervasive. She has a right to speak her mind, but in my opinion it was very poor judgement on her part to cover that topic in her assignment. anybody with sense knows that is playing with fire. I don't condone what happened to her, but that was a pretty dumb choice of topic. what did she expect would happen? I mean, hispanic kids here in my city have actually left school in oranized protest over this topic. It's not relegated to the adults.

    i really don't buy it that she was just completing an assignment. I would have to hear more about it I guess. like, what provoked the Hispanic kids, other than just the sign?

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • hypnoticmix's picture
    hypnoticmix
    33

    The only people who have an excuse in this matter are the little kids as unfortunate as their actions were. I hope the adults involved took the opportunity to teach them something wise about responding to things like this.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • wackdoodle's picture
    wackdoodle
    34

    Jillness - no I refuse to listen to any career politician. Any or all of the candidates can continue to promise the moon all they like - but do not honestly think that they will be able to deliver on any of their pie-in-the-sky promises. And yes it was rather articulate considering my pounding migraine.

    And what exactly does anything that he's said recently in staged rehearsed speeches have to do with asking someone to forgo being a delegate because they called some children 'monkeys'. You seem to be comparing Apples to Asphalt.

    And listen to Barack speak? No, thank you I have a life to lead and the man is so freaking long winded and full of hot-air that I think I'd prefer to listen to people getting their teeth drilled without novocaine to hearing one of his pseudo- "I have a Dream" speeches. He should actually audition for Man of La Mancha. Geez I thought Bill Clinton was long winded and full of hot-air but Barack is currently on-par and about to surpass him with all of the posturing. Bring back Jimmy Carter! He was straight forward , to-the-point and done.

    Yes, I can fault/blame some politician and his political team of vipers for trying to censor someone's free speech, when it was not offensive or meant to be offensive. And when failing that they remove them from a position that they had "earned".

    I "studied" Barack back when he first ran for IL legislature. As yet I've seen nothing original or special from him or about him to warrant me devoting time to pushing for his election. I've been politically aware since I was 7 - way back in 1978 when I cast my mother ballot for her at out local polling place and then started volunteering for our small local democratic office. I've said it before I've never missed an election or not cast a ballot since I turned 18, 18 years ago. Barack's campaign and supporters seem to be really dead-set on trying to sell him and his ideas as something new, when it's all old hat.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • hypnoticmix's picture
    hypnoticmix
    37

    Sure we do KrisSugar she said it wasn't and that she refers to her own kids as Monkeys.

    "the woman "came outside and told the children to quit playing in the tree like monkeys." The woman says she didn't want the children to get hurt, and she even calls her own grandchildren "monkeys."

    The context and intent is all laid out here. The people who asked her to step down were reacting to an anticipated reaction which may or may not have ever come but in any case they clearly went way too far.

    As for the young lady who wrote the report, you can't blame her because some kids just aren't street wise. Some kids are what they should be, innocent. There was no ill intent in her report and as far as I'm concerned it was an adolescents very basic expression of patriotism.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Jillness's picture
    Jillness
    38

    You read my mind, mondaymoos!

    I think some people in this world are highly educated and knowledgable. I don't care how long they go on, if they are insightful, I will listen to them and evaluate what they said.

    I think it is sad that our politics have gotten to the point where we nit pick what people affiliated with the campaign have to say, more than the actual candidates themselves.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Jillness's picture
    Jillness
    39

    hypnoticmix, keep in mind you are only hearing this woman's perspective...not the children's or the mothers.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • mondaymoos's picture
    mondaymoos
    41

    And if it was nothing but the sign, KrisSugar? In my experience, high school kids fight over a lot less than this instance. You don't need much to be provoked at that age.

    I don't think she was "playing with fire" by choosing this topic. Living in Arizona, it'd be a relevant debate topic, and something that I would choose. Why would you make a protest sign for something that held no meaning to you or anyone else in the class?

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • hypnoticmix's picture
    hypnoticmix
    42

    Well I can gather what the mothers perspective is Jillness. Her perspective is that racist called my kids monkeys and the kids perspectives was hey that lady called us monkeys and now is that lady is a racist because she called us monkeys.

    There reaction to what was said doesn't mean that is what the lady meant. It is the intent that should dictate terms not the reaction.

    25 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Jillness's picture
    Jillness
    43

    "There reaction to what was said doesn't mean that is what the lady meant. It is the intent that should dictate terms not the reaction."

    Of course. But I have known many racists that have said things like "jungle monkeys" when talking about african american people. We don't really know WHAT she